Keep Dallas Observer Free
At one point, citing The Lord of the Rings, two unusual lawsuits filed in Texas seek to invalidate the federal election results. They are calling for the annulment of every vote in the election, won by President Joe Biden. Every member of Congress is also absent.
Lawyers say they don’t stand a chance.
Filed by attorneys Paul Davis and Kellye SoRelle, lawsuits claim changes to electoral procedures implemented across the country violated the Help America Vote Act of 2002. The two initially filed on behalf of conservative Latino groups for Trump, Blacks for Trump and others. They have since gone their separate ways and are pursuing separate lawsuits. Davis said they were basically the same. SoRelle did not respond to a request for comment.
Failure to comply with the Help America Vote Act “deprived every American citizen … in the 2020 election,” the lawsuits say. It demands that federal courts take control of the government until a new Congress
The Help America Vote Act was enacted to address allegations of “2000 election fraud”. It set out minimum requirements that the prosecution’s allegations were not confirmed in the 2020 election. The requirements set out obligations regarding mail-in ballots, mail-in voter registration, voting processes. ‘Identification of highly detailed voters and others that legal claims have not been met.
According to the original complaint, federal and state officials engaged in “selective enforcement” to fraudulently certify the election as valid. They failed to meet these demands by using “illegal state rights claims,” according to the original lawsuit.
“The evidence that will come forward in this trial will establish an intentional concert of conduct between federal, state and local officials and various partisan businesses which should be viewed as a boot to the throat of any American who believes that the Constitution of the States -United guarantee to every citizen the right to a government elected by the people ”, we read in the trial.
Legal and electoral experts are not so sure. They say these efforts have no legs. For example, Barry Burden, director of the Center for Election Research at the University of Wisconsin, said: Living room the basis for complaints is illogical and misunderstands the Help America Vote Act as well as the relationship between the US Constitution, federal law, and state election laws.
The names of lawyers can ring a bell.
Davis was the lawyer who lost his job after posting videos of himself on Instagram on Capitol Hill during the Jan.6 uprising.
When Congress ratified the election vote on Jan.6, Davis stood outside. “We’re all trying to get into the Capitol to stop this,” he said in one of the video clips. Davis was not arrested because authorities said there was no evidence he had committed an overt act of violence. protested peacefully that day. Davis calls his trial “the trial of the people.”
“I am convinced that we have the evidence we need to prove our case. If the courts will do the right thing, everyone’s guessing, ”Davis told the Observer.
SoRelle, a lawyer from Texas, made headlines when she posted a video in November that purported to show electoral fraud in Detroit. He claimed someone was bringing ballots after the count was stopped in Michigan. It turned out they were just a film crew leaving a counting center. She is also listed as the general counsel for the Oath Keepers, an anti-government far-right militia allegedly involved in the Capitol Riot.
Their costumes name prominent figures, such as United States House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, and Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg – oh, as well as all the current members of the 117th Congress as well as every state governor and the full list of state secretaries.
The only plaintiff whose full name is included in the original lawsuit is Joshua Macias, co-founder of the Vets for Trump group. Macias was also at the Capitol on January 6 and faces a court request to revoke his bail from a previous arrest. The arrest came in November after he and a friend brought a semi-automatic rifle and samurai sword to a ballot processing center in Philadelphia.
Ciara Torres-Spelliscy, a member of the Brennan Center for Justice at the NYU School of Law, said Living room, “This legal effort to declare Congress illegitimate will be the subject of amicable laughter and could lead to penalties for the lawyer who makes such a claim.”
As if the claims weren’t bizarre enough, a motion attached to the original lawsuit cited The Lord of the Rings in its demand to have the entire US government, except the judiciary, in “stewardship”. Stewards feature prominently in the elven-filled land of Middle-earth. “Gondor has no king,” the lawsuit says.
Davis said people took a breath The Lord of the rings reference out of proportion. “The media made it such a big deal and acted as I quoted it [the movie] as a legal authority, presumably to distract from the merits of the case, “he said.” It was a line used as an analogy. Lawyers often make analogies to literature and pop culture. ”
Just in case the judges struggle to understand this analogy, which would be tragic since the rest of the trial is gibberish, a footnote with an explanation is provided:
During the epic trilogy, the rightful King of Gondor had relinquished the throne. Since only the rightful king could sit on the throne of Gondor, a steward was appointed to manage Gondor until the return of the king, known as “Aragorn”, at the end of the story. This analogy is applicable since there is now in Washington, DC, a group of individuals calling themselves the President, Vice President, and Congress who have no legitimate claim to rule the American people. As a result, as stated in the draft temporary prohibition order, as a remedy, the court should appoint a group of special masters (the “stewards”) to control the power of the illegitimate president until this constitutional crisis can. be resolved by a peaceful settlement. legal proceedings of a preliminary injunction hearing and a jury trial on the merits. “
(Editor’s note: Hopes for him that Davis’s understanding of Election Law is better than his grip on classic JRR Tolkien work. In the meantime, he might want to keep an eye out for nerdy guys in costumes. ‘elves who seek to hate him with inhalers. “Forsaken” the throne. The nerve.)
Members of Trump’s cabinet are the American equivalent of stewards in Gondor. Sticking to that analogy, they would run the country until Trump returns. It is a happy fate for Gondor, not so much for American democracy.
(Editor’s note 2: of course, other analogies with The Lord of the Rings also work. Mike Pence = Nazgûl, how are you?)
(Editor’s Note 3: I AM NOT A GEEK.)
Keep the Dallas Observer free … Since we started the Dallas Watcher, he was defined as the free and independent voice of Dallas, and we would like to keep it that way. Provide our readers with free access to cutting edge coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with bold reporting, elegant writing, and staff who have won it all, from the Society’s Sigma Delta Chi Award for Feature Writing of Professional Journalists for the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with the existence of besieged local journalism and the decline in advertising revenue having a bigger impact, it is more important than ever for us to rally support for funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our “I Support” membership program, which allows us to continue to cover Dallas without any payment walls.